| Comp | Season | Date | Home | Score | Away | Scorers | Video | Attendance | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FAC1 | 1885-1886 | 17/10/1885 | Bolton Wanderers | 6-0 | Eagley | Gregory, Fallon 2, Hough, Bullough, Opponent (og) | Unknown | Win | |
| FAC1R | 1881-1882 | 12/11/1881 | Eagley | 0-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Steel R | Unknown | Win | |
| FAC1 | 1881-1882 | 22/10/1881 | Bolton Wanderers | 5-5 | Eagley | Atherton, Gleaves, Struthers W, Opponent (2 og) | Unknown | Draw |